Need help ordering? Call us 718-874-0102

Home > Baby Sling and Carrier Comparison Chart

Baby Sling and Carrier Comparison Chart






 

Learning
Curve

Breast-
feeding

Long
Comfort

Tight Wrap/
Close Carry

Adjustability

Versatility

Padded
Shoulder

Padded
Rails

BABY WRAPS

Didymos

moderate

great

great

great

great

best

no

n/a

Storchenwiege Wrap

moderate

great

great

great

great

best

no

n/a

Moby Wrap

some

good

great

great

great

best

no

n/a

Gypsy Mama Wraps

some

good

good

good

great

great

no

no

RING SLINGS

Lightly Padded Maya

easy

great

good

good

great

good

yes

no

Zolowear Ring Slings

easy

great

OK

good

great

good

no

no

TaylorMade Sling

easy

great

good

good

great

good

no

no

POUCHES

Hotslings Pouch

easy

difficult

good

good

no

least

no

yes

SOFT STRUCTURED CARRIERS

Ergo Baby Carrier

easy

ok

great

great

great

good

n/a

n/a

Pikkolo Baby Carrier

easy

ok

great

great

great

good

n/a

n/a

MEI TAI

Freehand Mei Tai

easy

ok

good

great

great

least

no

n/a

Hip Carriers

Scootababy

easy

ok

good

great

great

least

no

n/a



All of these carriers are excellent, depending on your needs. (I intentionally carry only slings that will last you from birth through at least 35 pounds.) There is no absolute necessity to switch slings mid-stride. Decide which features mean the most to you, then find the carrier that excells in that area. Having said that, many people find it convenient to have several different baby carriers around (in the car, for hiking, for bed time, etc.). Particularly when the baby hits about 20 lbs, many people purchase a carrier that spreads the weight over both shoulders.

If you are still having trouble deciding, here are a few of my make or break recommendations:

  • If two people of very different sizes will be sharing one sling, the Maya Wrap Sling and TaylorMade Sling adjust across the widest range.
  • If the sling will be used for extended walking trips, either the Ergo, Pikkolo, Didymos, Moby Wrap, or Maya Wrap will be the most comfortable.
  • If someone has back, neck, or shoulder problems, either the Didymos, Moby Wrap, or Gypsy Mama would be best, depending on the problem.
  • If in doubt, anyone will love the Maya Wrap Sling for young babies. The Ergo Carrier or Pikkolo are sure winners for toddlers.





You are Currently Viewing: Baby Sling and Carrier Comparison Chart

Newsletter Sign Up